Well neat. I think you know this pretty much includes everyone that joined a discussion in... the last few years or so *cough* /s (fyi, the /s signals sarcasm).Misty wrote:I mean they need to actively participate in discussions and be willing to put aside personal feelings in the interest of what is actually fair. This means they need to be willing to persist in a debate instead of just agreeing to disagree. If anyone has a reasonable claim that one of these representatives is somehow unqualified, that needs to be considered, and if there's any reasonable doubt, they lose their position. They're still entitled to express their opinion and have it listened to, but their consent is no longer required to make a decision.
To an actual point though: Who decides if an individual has those traits?
One might add that if you declare one decision coming from only the mods as invalid you would therefore declare every decision coming from only mods as invalid. Your thoughts?Misty wrote:If we do adopt this new system, the only real question I can think of is how to deal with records submitted while a debate is in progress. [...] Should that freeze be applied retroactively, and if so, how far back?
Come to think of it, that's probably a question that needs to be answered whatever system we choose...
Interesting. That might be some common ground everyone could potentially agree on. But how do we find out if thats the case?Nika wrote:The moderators couls become neutral without the right to vote, but with the right to decide on the voting options
I fail to see how this is related to the topics discussed in this thread. Most people would probably agree that having an inactive admin doesnt really help, but how is this important in the context of setting up a new legislation system?Nika wrote:The last step would be to force power into handing us over the site, or create our own subreddit to have controll.
I ld really love to hear your stance on: "In your opinion, which group of people is required to approve of the proposed system or make the decision for a different system?"
If you were going to answer and I am just going ahead to fast because of timezones or something else, I am sorry.